The Duel at Pinehurst

The Preamble

Stewart had just rammed home a monster putt on the 16th green, an improbable, double-breaking downhiller from 25 feet to protect his tie atop the leaderboard with Mickelson. Stewart and Hicks began surveying Stewart’s putt, and Mickelson and his caddie, Jim “Bones” Mackay, began analyzing Mickelson’s putt.

“Later Payne told me he heard Phil and Bones reading that putt. Payne remembered that putt from his practice rounds, and he thought they were over-reading the break,” says Dick Coop, the Chapel Hill-based sports psychologist who counted Stewart as a client.

Mickelson missed his putt to the right. Hicks had no doubt that Stewart would pour his putt into the center of the cup for a birdie and a one-stroke lead.

“It was a gimme,” Hicks says. “He hadn’t missed inside 4 feet all week.”

The Putt

Then followed one of the most famous 18th holes ever played in major championship history. Mickelson — two shots to the back-right corner of the green of the par-four 18th, 25 feet away. Stewart — a drive, a pitch-out from thick rough and a 78-yard wedge shot to 15 feet short of the back-left hole location.

“Payne had a better chance to make his putt than I did to make mine,” Mickelson said. “His putt was uphill and mine was sidehill with a lot of break.”

“I knew if I missed and gave him a free run, there was a very good chance it would go in.” -Phil Mickelson

Mickelson aimed about 2 feet right of the hole and rolled a good putt, but the ball stopped just an inch to the right of the hole.

The stage was now Stewart’s. One putt for a win, two for a tie and a Monday playoff.

Mickelson stood to the side with Mackay. “I knew if I missed and gave him a free run, there was a very good chance it would go in,” Mickelson said.

What if?

What-ifs are as infinite as the stars and as worthless as old war bonds. But they can be tantalizing to reflect upon: What if Stewart misses his putt?

Amy Mickelson was back home in Scottsdale, Ariz., about to go into labor with the birth of the couple’s first child. Mackay had carried a beeper all weekend that would register a message from Amy that delivery was imminent; Phil pledged to walk off the golf course at any point to board a private plane and rush home to his wife’s side. Already Amy and her doctor delayed delivery by a day with medication on Saturday night; she watched the final round on the sofa with her pelvis propped up on pillows to prevent the baby dropping any further.

“I’m telling you, Payne would have refused the championship and said, ‘We’ll come back.’ The only fair thing to do under those circumstances would have been to come back at an agreed-to date.” -Tom Meeks, USGA

“I was totally in tears,” she said. “The worst thing that could happen was I have the baby Saturday night and he’s leading the U.S. Open.”

“I have a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity,” Mickelson said. “The U.S. Open is played every year. If that beeper goes off, I’m out of here.”

Golf Digest posed the What-If scenario to Tom Meeks, at the time senior director of rules and competitions with the USGA.

“It’s one of those hypotheticals where we’ll never know what would have happened,” Meeks said in 2005 upon the Open’s return to Pinehurst. “I’m glad the USGA didn’t have to make a decision (if Mickelson had left to be with Amy). I have my own thoughts. I would have said — and I think Payne would have said — ‘You’re not going to give me the U.S. Open because he can’t play tomorrow.’ I’m telling you, Payne would have refused the championship and said, ‘We’ll come back.’ The only fair thing to do under those circumstances would have been to come back at an agreed-to date.”

Alas, we’ll never know. Payne Stewart made sure of it.

Lee Pace is a regular contributor to the Pinehurst Blog. He latest book, “The Golden Age of Pinehurst—The Rebirth of No. 2,” is available in all retail shops at Pinehurst.